NWCCSAY provides trophies to the first and second place teams for Passers and Wings divisions in the spring and fall seasons.
For the NWCCSAY  Passer, and Wings divisions a win has a value of 3 points, a tie has a value of 1 point, and a loss has a value of 0 points
Spring Season: No playoffs in the spring season
1.   Most Points earned (Win = 3 pts; Tie = 1 pt; Loss = 0 pts)
2.   Most Wins
3.   Least Losses
4.   Result of head to head games during the season.
5.   Result of all games during the season using net goal differential (Max of 3 goals per game)
6.   Result of all games during the season with fewest goals allowed (Max of 3 goals per game)
7.   Coin flip.
Fall Ohio SAY State Tournament
For passer and wing divisions, NWCCSAY is allotted 4 teams slots for state tournament play (1 team each of
male and female passer and wing divisions).  The State Tournament Committee conducts a drawing of all Ohio
areas/districts for additional team openings.
If NWCCSAY sends teams to the State Tournament, NWCCSAY determines which teams are eligible to go and pays the registration fee.
For Fall 2004, NWCCSAY won a draw to send one additional female passer team to the state tournament.
For Fall 2005, NWCCSAY won a draw to send one additional female passer, one additional male passer, and
one additional female wing team to the state tournament.
For Fall 2006, NWCCSAY won a draw to send one additional team each of female passer, male passer, 
male wing, and female wing to the state tournament.
For Fall 2007, NWCCSAY sent an additional male and female passer team to the state tournament.
Striker, Kicker, Minor and Senior divisions have separate qualifiers to determine eligibility for the state tournament.
Fall Season: Ties for trophies and State Tournament
1.   Most Points earned (Win = 3 pts; Tie = 1 pt; Loss = 0 pts)
2.   Most Wins
3.   Least Losses
4.   Result of head to head games during the season.
5.   Result of all games during the season using net goal differential (Max of 3 goals per game).
6.   Fewest goals allowed (Max of 3 goals per game)
7a.  For 2 team tie:
       Playoff game next day.  No tie game, teams will go directly into sudden death period without goalies (one
       standard length quarter), the team that scores the first goal during this sudden death period is the winner.
       If teams are still tied, the teams then go to a goal shootout to determine the winner.  The shoot-out is to
       be moved to a stand-alone goal to allow the next scheduled game to proceed, as necessary.  This
       shoot-out will involve a series of five (5) penalty kicks per team, taken alternately.  Each team will select
       one (1) goalie and five (5) shooters, who will take one (1) shot each.  The goalie may be substituted, but
       once substituted, a goalie may not come back during a series of shots.  A coin toss will be used to
       determine which team will go first.  The team with the most goals out of five (5) shots is the winner.  If still
       tied, another set of shooters is chosen and another series of five (5) penalty kicks will be taken.  This
       continues until there is a winner.  Once a shooter has shot, s/he may not shoot again until all of his team
       members have shot.
7b.  For 3 team tie:
      Shootout round robin next day.